Sign in to mark it as listened, rate it and keep notes.
About the artist
Protomartyr is an American post-punk band from Detroit, Michigan, formed in 2010, featuring Joe Casey's vocals and Greg Ahee's guitar. Known for their art punk and noise rock sound, they have released seven studio albums to date.
About the album
"Relatives in Descent" is Protomartyr's fourth studio album, released in 2017, and is noted for being darker and more philosophical than previous works. Recorded in warm California, the album features seamlessly flowing songs and incorporates violin, influenced by The Raincoats and Mica Levi.
Meanings
While not a concept album, its lyrics, described as "soapbox poetry" and "Joycean," delve into philosophical questions and serious issues. Lead singer Joe Casey stated the album was influenced by the physical toll of touring and the "mildew smell" after his house flooded.
Why it's rated so high
The album received widespread critical acclaim, earning an 85 on Metacritic and being named among the year's best by many publications. Critics lauded Joe Casey's "sensational" "soapbox poetry" and "elite wordsmith" lyrics, alongside the "expertly played" music.
Career and historical context
This is Protomartyr's fourth studio album and their first release through Domino Recording Company. It followed extensive touring, with the band seeking a different recording environment to avoid creative ruts.
Fun facts
The band chose to record in California for its warmth, a change from their usual cold Michigan recording environment.
Guitarist Greg Ahee was inspired by violin sounds from The Raincoats' "Odyshape" and Mica Levi's "Under the Skin" score.
Lead singer Joe Casey said the album was "infected" by the smell of mildew after his house flooded.
The album's co-producer, Sonny DiPerri, is known for his work with Animal Collective.
Three tracks, "A Private Understanding", "My Children", and "Don't Go To Anacita", were released as singles.
Written by AI from the album's and artist's Wikipedia articles and the archive's notes. Double-check anything important.
The full story
Relatives in Descent is the fourth studio album by American post-punk band Protomartyr released on 29 September 2017. Their first to be released through Domino Recording Company, the album is much darker and more philosophical than its predecessors. While lyrically not a concept album, it is produced so that many songs flow from one to another seamlessly. Relatives in Descent received critical acclaim upon release, with many publications ranking it one of the best albums of the year.
Recording
The band hired Sonny DiPerri to co-produce this album (known for his work with Animal Collective). In an interview, lead singer Joe Casey said that "we knew we wanted to go someplace different to record than the previous two records, so we wouldn't get in a rut [...] what was so great about Sonny was that he was very locked in to what we wanted." He said that the band "wanted to record somewhere warm and we went to California. Usually, we are recording in Michigan and it is characteristically cold." According to Casey, the change in recording location also helped them write more complicated songs than before.
Guitarist Greg Ahee "was kind of enthralled with a certain kind of violin sound we heard [...] on a Raincoats record called Odyshape and then he wanted violin on the record. At first we heard it, and we all just thought, 'Ah shit, I don't know if that's going to work or not.'" He was also influenced by Mica Levi's score to Under the Skin. Asked on the source of the album's direction, Casey said: "For this record, we had just come off the road after doing a lot of touring. There were a lot of aches and pains so there was a lot of references to guts and generally feeling unwell. After the tour, my house also flooded. Before then, it had this smell of smoke and dust. Now I've got this mildew smell on top of that and the combination of these sensations and smell kind of infected the record."
Release
The album was released on the 29th of September 2017 through Domino Recording Company.
The tracks "A Private Understanding", "My Children" and "Don't Go To Anacita" were released as singles on July 10, August 15 and October 27th respectively. The videos for "A Private Understanding" (directed by Tony Wolski and Trevor Naud) and "Don't Go To Anacita" (directed by Yoonha Park) were uploaded through the band's official YouTube channel on the aforementioned dates of their release.
Reception
Critical
The album, like its predecessors, received critical acclaim from several sources. According to Metacritic, the album has a "metascore" of 85 based on 25 reviews. It also has a score of 8.2 based on 21 reviews on the site AnyDecentMusic?.
In a perfect score review for The Guardian, Ben Beaumont-Thomas called the album "sensational" and praised Casey's "soapbox poetry" lyrics, noting that it "never becomes leaden or pedantic" despite tackling serious issues. "While his band has grown into a post-punk monster," wrote Ben Salmon for Paste, "Casey, too, has moved beyond his personal frets and frustrations and developed into a lyricist capable of clear and compelling commentary. He's a voice worth listening to." In another perfect score review, Danny Carter of Loud and Quiet noted that the cryptic nature of the Joycean lyrics "[help] the album steer clear of being a tacky "fake news" concept piece." The review also praised the "expertly played" music, and the publication would later go on to rank it the best album of the year. Adam-Turner Heffer of Drowned in Sound called it "fairly incredible", and praised "A Private Understanding" as the best song of the year. NME's Thomas Smith called Casey an "elite wordsmith", and wrote - in reference to the song - that the band "have proved that they can be that cereus, blooming in the dark times we inhabit – and continue blossoming into a formidable and vital band."
Tiny Mix Tapes's Sean Hannah, on the other hand, noted that "Casey is at his lyrical best when tackling philosophical questions obliquely rather than head on". Despite this, they praised "Protomartyr's commitment to crafting challenging, academic songs reflective of their harried social and political climate." In a similarly mixed review, Paul Thomson of Pitchfork - while praising the band's ambition - took issue with some of the "scattershot" song structures and the cryptic nature of the lyrics in comparison with the band's past releases: "[B]y inching away from the Detroit-centered world-building of previous Protomartyr records, Casey's sacrificed a certain amount of the thematic consistency that's helped past records hold their center; these songs here, for better and worse, splay out all over the map."
Accolades
The album would go on to receive other accolades as well: