Colts Neck
Annoyed at how long it took him to record in the studio, Springsteen decided to record the new songs as solo demos, intending to rerecord them with the E Street Band—Roy Bittan (piano), Clarence Clemons (saxophone), Danny Federici (organ), Garry Tallent (bass), Steven Van Zandt (guitar), and Max Weinberg (drums)—at a later date. He later told the author Warren Zanes: "The recordings were just meant to get us a jump start on work in the studio with the band. I'd always spent a lot of time writing in the studio. I was trying to be more efficient, I guess. Certainly trying to spend a little less money."
Springsteen tasked his guitar technician, Mike Batlan, with buying a simple tape recorder to work out some demos and tinker with arrangements. Batlan picked up a four-track TEAC 144 Portastudio recorder, a then-relatively new device that allowed musicians to perform a basic track first before adding additional parts on the remaining tracks. Springsteen believed these overdubbed instruments would help the band understand how the final track should sound. He and Batlan set the recorder up in the bedroom of his Colts Neck home. They connected the machine to two Shure SM57 microphones on stands. Springsteen played a Gibson J-200 acoustic guitar, overdubbing harmonica, percussion, mandolin, and glockenspiel. The demos were recorded between December 17, 1981, and January 3, 1982. Most of the basic tracks (vocals and acoustic guitar) were finished in four to six takes.
Springsteen and Batlan mixed the sound by plugging the recorder into an Echoplex, a tape delay effects machine, and using an old water-logged Panasonic boombox as a mix-down deck to bring the final mix onto a cassette tape. In Songs, Springsteen stated he recorded this way because he "found the atmosphere in the studio to be sterile and isolating". Fifteen songs appeared on the initial cassette tape: "Bye Bye Johnny", "Starkweather"/"Nebraska", "Atlantic City", "Mansion on the Hill", "Born in the U.S.A.", "Johnny 99", "Downbound Train", "The Losin' Kind", "State Trooper", "Used Cars", "Wanda (Open All Night)", "Child Bride", "Pink Cadillac", "Highway Patrolman", and "Reason to Believe".
After the tracks were mixed, Springsteen sent the tape to his manager-producer Jon Landau with two pages of handwritten notes about arrangements and mixes. According to the biographer Peter Ames Carlin, Landau was "impressed by the power of the songs' minimalist narratives" and the "yelping desperation in the performances". Springsteen recorded two more songs over the following months at Colts Neck: "The Big Payback" between March and April, and "My Father's House" on May 25.
Attempted rerecordings
In April 1982, Springsteen and the E Street Band rehearsed the demos at Bittan's house before regrouping at the Power Station in New York City to rerecord them for release on the next album. The band spent two weeks attempting full-band arrangements of the Colts Neck tracks, but Springsteen and his co-producers—Landau, Van Zandt, and Chuck Plotkin—were dissatisfied with the results. Springsteen, in particular, felt many of the full-band versions failed to capture the spirit of the demos, while Plotkin blamed the studio's "tendency to conventionalize sounds". Other songs from the tape, including "Born in the U.S.A.", "Downbound Train", "Child Bride" (rewritten as "Working on the Highway"), and "Pink Cadillac" proved successful in full-band arrangements. Continuing into May, the band also recorded newly-written songs, including "Glory Days", "I'm Goin' Down", "I'm on Fire", "Wages of Sin", and "Johnny Bye-Bye".
Despite the band's productivity and excitement about the recorded material, Springsteen remained focused on the rest of the Colts Neck songs. Attached to the cassette's "authentic" sound, he carried it with him in his jeans pocket, unsure of what to do with the material. Throughout June, Springsteen and his co-producers began mixing and sequencing the acoustic and …