The album's songs were recorded between June 1974 and January 1975 at various locations. Dedicated recording sessions were held in December 1974 at Quadrafonic Studios in Nashville with Elliot Mazer producing, repeating the context in which Harvest was recorded. While its predecessor features songs inspired by the beginning of Young's relationship with Carrie Snodgress, Homegrown features songs inspired by the end of that relationship. 1974 was a prolific time for Young as a writer, writing both the dozen songs that were slated for Homegrown as well as many others that would be sprinkled throughout his 1970s albums or go unreleased until 2020's Neil Young Archives Volume II: 1972–1976.
In July, CSNY embarked on a stadium tour of North America, their first since the 1970 tour that featured on 4 Way Street. To prepare, the band convened at Young's Northern California ranch to rehearse their sprawling repertoire. During the rehearsals, Young recorded several new songs on June 15 as a solo performer, on the 16th with bassist Tim Drummond, and on the 17th with Crosby, Stills and Nash.
On June 15, Young recorded solo demos of "Love Is a Rose", "The Old Homestead", "Love/Art Blues", "Through My Sails" and "Barefoot Floors". The lullaby "Barefoot Floors" was first released in 2021 on Young's website. It was also covered by Nicolette Larson on her album Sleep, Baby, Sleep. The lyrics to "Love/Art Blues" lament the tension between Young's personal and creative priorities in life. He told Constant Meijers, "Those girls always get jealous when you're working on something with great intensity."
On the 16th, Young returned to his home studio with bassist Tim Drummond. That day he recorded at least eight songs, including master takes of "Homefires" and "Love Is a Rose". He performed the songs right after each other, in front of a roaring fire. He also recorded the backing track to "Pardon My Heart", which saw additional overdubs before release on the 1975 album Zuma. He also attempted "Love/Art Blues", "New Mama" and "The Old Homestead". The confessional solo piano piece "L.A. Girls and Ocean Boys" was also recorded that day. Its lyrics were interpolated into "Danger Bird" on Zuma. Young also recorded the newly written "Hawaiian Sunrise" with Drummond. Young remembers writing the song during the rehearsals in his memoir Special Deluxe: "At the ranch, while rehearsing for the tour, I wrote a new song called "Hawaiian Sunrise." It seemed like every day I had another new song. With all the changes going on in my life, I wrote songs daily, turning the changes into something. I always looked at occasions in life as inspirations for songs. We were singing so easily. It was flowing. We were all high on weed and excited. Crosby called up Peter Fonda, and we sang "Hawaiian Sunrise" for him over the phone from my cabin living room, all four of us. It was the best we ever sang it. To this day, I'm sorry we weren't recording it. That is one of the biggest lessons I have learned about recording music. 'Get it while it's hot.' Every song has its moment, and we let that one escape into a telephone."
On June 17, Young recorded with CSNY, producing the take of "Through My Sails" that ended up on Zuma. The group helped Young with a new arrangement of "New Mama", made an attempt at "Love/Art Blues", and recorded additional vocals for the previous day's take of "Hawaiian Sunrise".
During the 1974 CSNY tour, Young debuted 17 new songs on stage. Two days before the group's performance at Wembley Stadium, Young recorded another new song, "White Line", with the Band's Robbie Robertson. It was recorded at Ramport Studios in London on September 12, 1974. The Band had served as one of CSNY's opening acts during their summer tour. The duo recorded the song on acoustic guitars, with Robertson providing flourishes to complement Young's playing.
After the CSNY tour, Young traveled to Amsterdam for a week and a half in late September/early October with Graham Nash, …