The Glow Pt. 2 marked a shift in Elverum's writing from the "short, straightforward pop songs" of the Microphones' previous studio album It Was Hot, We Stayed in the Water to a more abstract, symbolic style, although it uses "similar sounds and songwriting styles". Elverum's lyrics range from being highly specific to "macrocosmic" in scale. The lyrics are performed in a stream of consciousness manner and frequently reference nature and the Pacific Northwest while exhibiting a sense of longing. The songs are equally diverse, ranging from ambient pieces, to acoustic folk songs, to "expansive multitracked forces of nature", with multi-tracking being utilised on songs such as "I'll Not Contain You". Sudden piano stabs and abrupt rhythm and key changes are present throughout The Glow Pt. 2. Elverum employs multiple unique production techniques, such as compartmentalising individual notes to separate audio tracks and arranging the tracks to perform the melody in sequence. "Call-and-response" panning is featured on the song "Instrumental".
The theme of fire is central to the album. The fire on the artwork is meant to be a representation of "the Glow"; this was first introduced on the fourth track of It Was Hot, We Stayed in the Water, which Elverum stated was a "glowing window that you see as you are freezing to death in the snow, or the light you go into supposedly when you die". Of the presence of "the Glow" on The Glow Pt. 2, Elverum said it represents "one's inner 'life force'". Themes of flesh, blood, water, wood, life, death and overcoming depression are also central to the album.
The opening track "I Want Wind to Blow" was recorded on January 1, 2001. Elverum wrote the melody in Philadelphia while on tour. The countermelody to the song is played in the key of G major, though the main melody is played in a higher register. The instrumentation for the song was performed by Elverum; he recorded the piano tracks far away from the microphone to capture the natural sounds of the piano in the studio, which would otherwise not be picked up. The guitar sections were intended to resemble the sound of water by miking the amp and strings while two stereos were used to create stereophonic sound. The song records Elverum scraping a snare drum.
The title "I Want Wind to Blow" was explained by Elverum: "I want crazy events to happen to me. I'm tired of gray. Give me black or white." His relationship to Khaela Maricich and its subsequent dissolution are mentioned on the song with the opening lyrics referencing their breakup, the changing weather of the time (with the weather serving as a metaphor for his emotions), and their Beach Boys cover band The Thunder Clouds.
Elverum explains that the title track is about the desire to wallow in self pity: "Being annoyed at your heart for still beating." It features the line "my blood flows harshly," which Elverum holds for 14 seconds. Dan Hancox of The Guardian compared Elverum's mood on the song to that of a "disaster survivor". "The album's third track, "The Moon", features acoustic guitar chords alongside Elverum whispering lyrics, with him having found the inspiration for the song in his routine nightly walks. The first song entitled "Instrumental" features finger-snaps. The foghorn is a recurring motif throughout The Glow Pt. 2. "Map" opens with a brief interlude that consists of a foghorn, which leads into distorted organs, a kick drum, and vocals. The track finishes in the same manner it starts, with the sound of a foghorn. "I Felt My Size" opens with atmospheric noise and chaotic guitar strumming. It then transitions to a simplistic melody accompanied by metaphorical lyrics, childlike vocals, synths, pianos and double-timed drums, before concluding with a foghorn.
The songs "I'll Not Contain You" and "I Felt Your Shape" discuss the "impossible desire to hold on to fleeting things". Elverum stated that "I Felt Your Shape" is about hugging someone in a sensitive empathetic manner instead of a …