Initial recording sessions (and departure of Hal Lindes)
The initial recording sessions for Brothers in Arms took place between 2 November and 21 December 1984 at AIR Studios on the island of Montserrat, a British overseas territory in the Caribbean. Before arriving at Montserrat, Knopfler had written all the songs and rehearsed them with the band; which, at the time of recording, was himself (vocals, guitar), John Illsley (bass, backing vocals), Hal Lindes (guitar), Alan Clark (piano, organ), Terry Williams (drums) and new member Guy Fletcher (synthesisers, backing vocals).
The studio itself was small, with a 20-by-25-foot (6 m × 8 m) recording space that offered virtually no isolation. "It was a good-sounding studio," Dorfsman later recalled, "but the main room itself was nothing to write home about. The sound of that studio was the desk," referring to the Neve 8078 board. Knopfler and Dorfsman utilised the main studio's limited space to best effect, placing the drum kit in the far left corner, facing the control room. They placed the piano in a tight booth in the far right corner, miked with AKG C414s. The Hammond B3 was placed nearby, with its Leslie speaker either wedged into the soundproof entryway to the control room or even set up outdoors. Illsley's bass amplifier was recorded inside a small vocal booth with a Neumann FET 47 and a DI unit. Knopfler's amplifiers were miked with 57s, 451s, and Neumann U67s. Fletcher's synths were placed in the control room.
Brothers in Arms was one of the first albums recorded on a Sony 24-track digital tape machine. The decision to move to digital recording came from Knopfler's constant striving for better sound quality. "One of the things that I totally respected about him," Dorfsman observed, "was his interest in technology as a means of improving his music. He was always willing to spend on high-quality equipment." However, they encountered a defective batch of recording tape at AIR Studios, which would result in the loss of part or all of three album tracks.
Hal Lindes left the band early in the sessions. According to Illsley, this was due to social disagreements, with Lindes spending too much time with his girlfriend (and future wife) and not enough with the rest of the band, leading to questions about his commitment. As had been the case with the earlier recording of Making Movies, Knopfler then took on the recording the majority of guitar parts himself.
During the recording of "Money for Nothing", the signature sound of Knopfler's guitar may have been enhanced by a "happy accident" of microphone placement. Knopfler was using his Gibson Les Paul going through a Laney amplifier. While setting up the guitar amplifier microphones in an effort to get the "ZZ Top sound" that Knopfler sought, guitar tech Ron Eve, who was in the control room, heard the "amazing" sound before Dorfsman was finished arranging the mics. "One mic was pointing down at the floor," Dorfsman remembered, "another was not quite on the speaker, another was somewhere else, and it wasn't how I would want to set things up—it was probably just left from the night before, when I'd been preparing things for the next day and had not really finished the setup." What they heard was exactly what ended up on the record; no additional touches were made during the mix.
Issues with drumming (Terry Williams and Omar Hakim); recruitment of Jack Sonni
In December 1984, six weeks into the recording sessions in Montserrat, the drum parts became an issue and Terry Williams was dismissed from the sessions. According to a later Sound on Sound magazine interview with Neil Dorfsman, he and Knopfler had decided that Williams' performances were unsuitable for the desired sound and feel of the album. Illsley, however, recalled in 1985 that it was Williams' studio nerves that made it difficult to record the best rhythm tracks as a band. Williams himself, meanwhile, has claimed that he had recorded all his drum parts to a click …