The album received numerous awards and accolades. Morissette and the album won five Juno Awards in 1996: Album of the Year, Single of the Year for "You Oughta Know", Female Vocalist of the Year, Songwriter of the Year and Best Rock Album. At the 1996 Grammy Awards, she won four awards: Best Female Rock Vocal Performance, Best Rock Song (both for "You Oughta Know"), Best Rock Album and Album of the Year; Morissette consequently tied with Carole King and Bonnie Raitt for the record of most Grammys won by a woman at a single ceremony, at the time. Glen Ballard was nominated as Producer of the Year, Non-Classical for the album's production.
"Ironic" was nominated for two 1997 Grammy Awards—Record of the Year and Best Music Video, Short Form—and won Single of the Year at the 1997 Juno Awards, where Morissette also won Songwriter of the Year and the International Achievement Award. The video Jagged Little Pill, Live, which was co-directed by Morissette and chronicled the bulk of her tour, won a 1998 Grammy Award for Best Music Video, Long Form.
In 1998, the album was ranked at No. 28 in the Top 100 Albums list of the Music of the Millennium, a nation-wide public survey conducted in the United Kingdom in 1999 by HMV music stores, in partnership with the Channel 4 television network and Classic FM radio. In 2005, Channel 4 included the album at No. 16 in the list 100 Best Albums of All Time.
In 2000, it was voted No. 51 in Colin Larkin's All Time Top 1000 Albums. In October 2002, Rolling Stone ranked it No. 31 on its Women In Rock – The 50 Essential Albums list. In 2003, the magazine ranked it No. 327 on its list of "The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time", and while left out of the 2012 update, the album's rank shot up to number 69 in the 2020 reboot of the list. The album was included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. The album also appears on the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and National Association of Recording Merchandisers' list of "200 Definitive Albums" at No. 26, and on Apple Music's "100 Best Albums" list at No. 31. The album ranked at No. 50 on Rolling Stone's 2012 list of "Women Who Rock: The 50 Greatest Albums of All Time". The album peaked at No. 1 on the US Billboard 200, making Morissette the first Canadian woman to top the chart. It also topped Billboard's "Best Selling Pop album of the 1990s". In 2022, Pitchfork ranked the album at No. 51 in its list of The 150 Best Albums of the 1990s.
Morissette's success with Jagged Little Pill was credited with leading to the introduction of female singers such as Fiona Apple, Shakira, Tracy Bonham, Meredith Brooks, and in the early 2000s, Pink, Michelle Branch, and fellow Canadian Avril Lavigne. American singer Katy Perry cites Jagged Little Pill as a significant musical inspiration, and opted to work with Morissette's frequent collaborator Ballard as a result. Perry stated, "Jagged Little Pill was the most perfect female record ever made. There's a song for anyone on that record; I relate to all those songs. They're still so timeless." Grammy Award winner Kelly Clarkson said of the album, "It made me a better writer. It made me a better singer." Avril Lavigne cited Jagged Little Pill as one of her all-time favorite albums, stating: "It is an album I can revisit over and over, belt every song, and never get sick of." In 2018, the album won the Polaris Heritage Prize Audience Award in the 1986–1995 category.
Benny Anderson of ABBA listed the album as one of the 6 soundtracks of his life: "I listened to this a lot when it came out, at a time when I wasn't writing pop songs any more. It was a remembrance of solid golden pop, from a fantastically talented woman with great writing and a great voice, and a very nicely produced album by Glen Ballard. It's one of the top 10 albums in my life when it comes to pop records, alongside Rumours and Hotel California."
In August 2021, Morissette began a tour for the album's 26th anniversary. The tour was scheduled to begin in …